21 January 2021
Political & Trend Analyst
A proverbial storm has developed around South Africa’s procurement, or the perceived lack thereof, of Covid-19 vaccines. People are understandably anxious and have many questions. I therefore compiled this note from publicly available information, and trust readers find it useful.
What is approved and available?
Currently (though this changes all the time), there are five approved vaccines available in the world. All of them require two shots, administered roughly three weeks apart. One must therefore distinguish between doses and number of people treated – two doses are needed for each person.
|Approved vaccines||Cost per shot and based on the required two doses, per person.||Storage and transport requirements||Comments|
|Pfizer/BioNTech||13$ per dose/$26 per person||-70ºC|
|Moderna||$32–$37 per dose/$60–$70 per person||-20ºC|
|Oxford/AstraZeneca||Available at $3 per dose/$6 per person through the Serum Institute of India.||2 to 8ºC (normal refrigeration temperatures)||Best option currently for developing countries due to:
AstraZeneca is licensing nine other producers (like the Serum Institute of India) and by doing that, aims to supply 3 billion doses this year.
|Sputnik V (Russia)||$10 per dose/$20 per person||2 to 8ºC||Phase 3 results not released yet, despite being approved for use in certain jurisdictions.|
|Sinovac (China)||$13,75 per dose/$27 per person||2 to 8 ºC||Phase 3 results not released yet, despite being approved for use in certain jurisdictions.|
The efficacy of these medicines varies considerably and is also determined whether one or two jabs are administered.
What is still in development?
The World Health Organisation (WHO) reports that some 50 vaccines are in development worldwide, so more and cheaper vaccines are sure to follow.
- The Johnson & Johnson vaccine will require only one shot, but it is still in its final trials and has not been approved yet. (The company has submitted its vaccine for approval in South Africa and the Aspen factory in Nelson Mandela Bay is under licence to manufacture it. Dr Glenda Gray is running the clinical trials for Johnson & Johnson in South Africa.)
- Other Chinese companies apart from Sinovac are also developing vaccines, as are companies in India.
What has been/is being distributed?
All vaccines must be cleared for use by the regulatory authorities in the recipient country. While the numbers change daily, 33 countries have acquired one or more of the five approved vaccines to date and have started inoculating citizens. Thirty countries are using Pfizer/BioNTech, four are using Sputnik V, one Sinovac and two Moderna. (Some countries use more than one vaccine.)
In practice, some countries are doing much less than the headlines suggest. Hungary has less than 5 000 people on Pfizer/BioNTech and another 3 000 on Sputnik; Mexico has 1 500 people on Pfizer/BioNTech (paid for by a private philanthropist).
The European Union acquired Pfizer/BioNTech vaccines centrally and started distribution among some of its members at the end of December 2020. (In November President Ramaphosa has launched a similar initiative for the African continent – see below.)
Wealthier countries are obviously better placed to buy the vaccines. To date, 53% of the estimated supply of all vaccines in phase three clinical trials (not just the five approved), has already been bought by countries that make up only 14% of the world’s population. Some countries bought enough doses to vaccinate their population three times. Canada bought for five times its population, the US for about three times, and the UK for two times. That does not mean they have that many vaccines, it must still be produced. In fact, both countries considered giving only one jab to stretch supplies further. At some point they will have too many and then vaccines are going to be given away… if they are still effective.
The springbok and wildebeest of the plains know that there is safety in numbers. The same goes for vaccines – pooling resources and buying on scale gives one a better chance of obtaining a vaccine at a good price. There are two programmes running for poorer countries to access the vaccine.
The Covax programme is run by the WHO / GAVI and involve 64 countries, philanthropic foundations and manufacturers. The richer countries pay more to subsidise poorer countries, and donors like the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation also contribute. To date, 2 billion doses have been acquired for Covax (enough to cover one billion people). South Africa is participating in this programme and has paid the 15% deposit required (R283 million). The country will receive doses for 6 million people. Covax was set-up in June.
On 8 November 2020 President Ramaphosa set up the African Union (AU) programme to acquire vaccines for the continent at large. The initiative supplements Covax. To date, 270 million doses have been acquired from AstraZeneca (through the Serum Institute of India), Pfizer and Johnson & Johnson (although the latter vaccine is not approved yet). It will be distributed according to population size (not case load) and South Africa will receive enough doses to vaccinate a further 6 million people. Finance will be available through the African Export Import Bank, repayable over five years. The AU is also negotiating with the World Bank on behalf of African countries for access to a further $5 billion in financing for vaccines.
Between these two collective programmes 12 million South Africans will be vaccinated.
The country is also negotiating with individual suppliers outside these initiatives. Vaccines for a further 750 000 people (1,5 million doses) will come from the Serum Institute of India – Treasury has confirmed that the heads of agreement have been agreed and delivery is expected in February. The table below summarises the status quo:
|Source||Number of people that will be vaccinated||Delivery|
|Covax programme||6 million people||From February|
|African Union programme||6 million people||Between March and June|
|Serum Institute of India||750 000 people||From February|
|12,75 million people||February to June|
Clearly, the popular narrative that South Africa has missed the boat because we did not deal with individual suppliers, is a bit off the mark.
Procurement is also not straightforward. The Serum Institute wants 100% payment upfront (which is tricky within Treasury rules), while Johnson & Johnson (pending approval) requires an insurance/indemnity arrangement should there be negative consequences from the use of the vaccine. Prices also vary widely – in December it was leaked in Belgium that various vaccine prices varied from $2,15 to $21,78 per shot! Easy to pay more than you have to….
The 12,75 million people for whom vaccines have been procured is about one third of the target population of 40 million government wishes to vaccinate. So, vaccines for another 18 million people will still have to be procured through Covax, the AU and direct negotiations.
The target of 40 million may be too ambitious. There are only about 40 million adults in the country and the vaccines are not authorised for children under 16. That implies a vaccination rate of 100% for all adults. (Judging by the number of teenagers infected at rage parties one can only hope for a speedy under-16 approval.)
The country’s 1,5 million health workers will be first in line for vaccination, followed by 16,5 million essential workers, people with co-morbidities and people over the age of 60. We should know by April when all the over 60s will be vaccinated.
Current estimates are that the vaccination programme will cost a total of about R10 billion. The money will be provided for in the February budget together with whatever other financing mechanisms are being considered.
With enough doses in the pipeline for 12,75 million South Africans, and more vaccines likely to be available soon, the attention must switch to the logistics of getting those doses from OR Tambo Airport to Kakamas and Mthatha and Ulundi. Not just the doses – also the syringes, the personnel and all other resources needed. It is a daunting logistical task – more so than the 2010 World Cup or the 1994 election, as the president pointed out. He therefore appointed an inter-ministerial cabinet committee to oversee the logistics. It also gives journalists a point of entry to keep the public informed and raise distribution problems. One hopes this committee will give weekly feedback. It will build trust.
- South Africa’s strategy has been to procure vaccines through two collective programmes: Covax and the AU. This has secured vaccines for 12 million people.
- The next step is to procure directly from individual manufacturers as their products become available at reasonable prices. The first direct agreement is with the Serum Institute of India, under licence from Oxford/AztraZeneca, and will deliver enough doses for 750 000 people (earmarked for health workers).
- Delivery will be between February and June, and by June we will have a good idea of how inoculation is proceeding.
- Supply of vaccines will increase globally and in South Africa. The Johnson & Johnson vaccine is in its final trials and up for approval. The Sputnik vaccine is being tested outside Russia, as is the Chinese vaccine (Sinovac). More vaccines are being developed by other players. It is now a scramble, but as more producers enter, there will be an abundance of supply.
- Prices vary widely and seem to be very negotiable. As supply increases prices should come down further.
- The remaining challenge for South Africa is to manage the coordination and distribution of vaccines. One step at a time.